• Our Practice
  • Our Team
    • Cameron Stracher
    • Andrew Lachow
    • Michelle Sawyer
    • Sarah Regan
    • Sara Tesoriero
  • Media Matters
  • Client News

Cameron Stracher

Media Matters

Why It’s So Hard to Win a “Hollywood-Stole-My-Idea” Case

Why It’s So Hard to Win a “Hollywood-Stole-My-Idea” Case

It is one of Hollywood’s most persistent lawsuits: an aspiring writer claims to have sent a screenplay, treatment, or pitch … Read More

AI in Hot Copy

AI in Hot Copy

A federal judge in the Southern District of New York has allowed a coalition of major news publishers to move … Read More

AI’s Legal Blind Spot(s)

AI’s Legal Blind Spot(s)

Artificial intelligence is reshaping how documentaries are made, generating archival imagery, reenactments, and visual effects that once required significant resources. … Read More

Free Speech Ends Where Defamation Begins

Free Speech Ends Where Defamation Begins

A federal judge has ruled that MyPillow founder Mike Lindell defamed election technology company Smartmatic by spreading baseless claims that … Read More

AI v. Authors: Round One to AI

AI v. Authors: Round One to AI

A recent court decision has shed light on how “fair use” applies to generative AI systems – a significant ruling … Read More

When Courts Punish Journalists, the Public Suffers

When Courts Punish Journalists, the Public Suffers

The First Amendment gives every member of the public the right to access court records and proceedings. As the Supreme … Read More

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • Next Page »

Media News

11/13 - A federal judge in Florida denied the BBC’s motion to dismiss President Trump’s $10 billion defamation lawsuit arising from a documentary that spliced together portions of his January 6, 2021, speech, allegedly creating the false impression that Trump directly encouraged violence at the Capitol. Judge Jeffrey Kuntz held that Trump plausibly alleged actual malice because the BBC combined statements made nearly 55 minutes apart, potentially demonstrating knowing or reckless disregard for the truth, and sufficiently alleged reputational harm. Although the court dismissed Trump’s separate claim under Florida’s deceptive trade practices statute, it allowed the defamation claim to proceed, emphasizing that Trump must still prove actual malice and damages at summary judgment or trial.

11/1 - A federal judge dismissed President Donald Trump’s $10 billion defamation lawsuit against The Wall Street Journal and Rupert Murdoch over an article reporting that Trump had sent a sexually suggestive birthday letter to Jeffrey Epstein in 2003. U.S. District Judge Darrin Gayles ruled that Trump failed to plausibly allege actual malice, finding that the newspaper conducted a thorough investigation, sought Trump's response before publication, and included his denials in the article, while emphasizing that a public figure's denial does not prevent journalists from publishing contrary information. The court dismissed the amended complaint with prejudice, preventing Trump from refiling the lawsuit in district court, although he may appeal.

10/29 - A federal district court in Florida granted summary judgment to Patrick Byrne, dismissing a defamation lawsuit brought by former Dominion Voting Systems executive Eric Coomer over allegations in the documentary The Deep Rig that Coomer helped rig the 2020 presidential election. Applying Colorado law, the court held that Coomer failed to establish by clear and convincing evidence that Byrne acted with actual malice – that is, that Byrne knew the allegations were false or subjectively entertained serious doubts about their truth. Although the court acknowledged that Byrne's failure to investigate and disregard of contrary evidence might constitute negligence, it concluded that even objectively false and harmful statements are protected under the actual malice standard when the defendant sincerely believes them to be true

10/12 - Including a plaintiff's response to allegedly defamatory statements in an article has led to an early dismissal for failure to plead negligence in a recent defamation case filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Texas against the firm's client, The Independent. In Heritage Ministries v. Independent Digital News & Media, Ltd., a conservative religious community in Texas sued The Independent for defamation based on an article about former Heritage members who left the community following traumatic birth experiences facilitated by the church's midwife. Heritage claimed it was defamed by several statements in the article and that the article did not include Heritage's responses to some of the allegations. The court, however, dismissed the Complaint after finding Heritage failed to sufficiently plead fault. Without concluding whether Heritage was a public figure, the court found that Heritage had not alleged that The Independent had been negligent in publishing the article. Specifically, the court found that Heritage's claim that its responses were not included was "plainly false" and highlighted the multiple statements and denials from Heritage quoted in the article. Thus, the court concluded that the "comprehensive inclusion of Heritage's responses demonstrates that Defendant exercised reasonable care in its reporting" and therefore Heritage had failed to plausibly allege the fault required to maintain a claim for defamation. 

10/1 - A New York State Supreme Court judge, in a case of first impression, has granted Newsweek’s summary judgment motion in a lawsuit Newsweek brought under New York’s anti-SLAPP law against Olivet University. Olivet had previously sued Newsweek, represented by the firm, for defamation in the Southern District of New York, which was dismissed by the federal court and affirmed by the Second Circuit on substantial truth and fair report grounds. Newsweek then sued Olivet to recover its attorneys’ fees in state court under the anti-SLAPP law, and after the court denied Olivet’s motion to dismiss, and Newsweek filed its answer, Newsweek moved for summary judgment, arguing that the dismissal in federal court meant the case lacked a substantive basis in law as required by the anti-SLAPP law. Judge Phaedra Perry-Bond agreed, granted Newsweek’s motion, and instructed Newsweek to file a motion for attorneys’ fees evidencing the damages it seeks under the anti-SLAPP law.


View All

Cameron Stracher, PLLC

1133 Broadway, Suite 516
New York, NY 10010

(646) 992-3850
email

Get the Media Matters newsletter delivered straight to your inbox!

The information presented on this website should not be construed to provide legal advice, nor does it constitute the formation of an attorney/client relationship.
©2026 Cameron Stracher. All Rights Reserved